The former Maury Loontjens Memorial Library at 35 Kingstown Road is a wood-frame building from 1976, with an addition and renovations finished in 1997. It sits on a small paved lot with 17 spaces, beside the Comfort Station that holds the Pier's public restrooms and next to the town's public safety complex. The library itself moved a short distance away to 25-27 Pier Marketplace, the former Belmont/IGA, and the Narragansett Times described the old Kingstown Road building as "much smaller."
Since then the building has gone through two town solicitations, one rejected bid and a broker search. At a late-October work session, the Town Council heard from the last two contenders. One would bring back Cool Beans Cafe alongside a restorative therapy and yoga studio. The other would open an arts center. When the town first went looking, it left room for a sale and for new homes on the site. Both finalists would keep the 1976 building standing and open to the public, and the council's real question now is whether it gets one tenant or two.
What the Town First Put on the Table
In January 2025 the town's request for proposals asked investors and developers to "repurpose or replace" the building. It offered three options: a long-term lease of the building for renovation, a long-term lease of the site for reconstruction, or a sale of the site and building "for development of appropriate business and/or residences." The town also said it would consider zoning changes as an incentive. It had not chosen a target use and said it was open to all proposals. It described the site as a way to link the Pier to the Town Beach, Ocean Road and Boon Street.
The steps since then, from the town's own bid records and local reporting:
- January 23, 2025. The investor-developer RFP, bid B25002, is published, with proposals due February 24.
- July 21, 2025. The Town Council votes to reject the only proposal, from GBC LLC/Venture, as recorded on the town's bid page.
- November 13, 2025. A new request goes out for a commercial broker or marketing firm to find a long-term tenant, with responses due December 18. A sale is no longer part of it.
- February 2, 2026. The council awards the broker contract to the only bidder.
- Late October 2026. The council hears two finalists at a work session and takes no vote. According to Uprise RI, it had already heard three other proposals in executive session before narrowing the field to two.
So the search started out allowing a sale, reconstruction or housing. By the time it reached a public session, the town was looking at a lease, and the two proposals left would both fill the existing rooms with uses residents walk into.
The Building Both Finalists Would Inherit
The 2025 RFP describes the building in detail. Its footprint is about 9,139 square feet. It has a crawl-space basement, a second-floor mezzanine and no elevator to the upper level. Including the public safety complex, the whole parcel is about 77,500 square feet, and the library used about 33,200 square feet of it. Those numbers explain why the two proposals overlap so easily. A cafe group asking for at least 6,000 square feet of ground-floor commercial space would still leave a large part of a 9,139-square-foot footprint unclaimed.
Uprise RI's account lays out the two proposals:
| Cafe and studio group | Arts center group | |
|---|---|---|
| Who is behind it | Led by a Narragansett resident, pairing a restorative therapy and yoga studio with Cool Beans Cafe | A theater education company founded in 2024, whose founder said she grew up in Narragansett |
| What goes inside | Cafe, studio, and a third retail space of about 1,500 square feet in the former children's library | Theater space, dance studio, music school and art studio, with Valerie Pringles' dance academy named as a possible partner |
| How much of the building | At least 6,000 square feet kept for ground-floor commercial use | The company would manage the whole building |
| Lease and money | A 10-year lease with an option to extend to 99 years, plus an 18-month abatement during which the town would keep paying taxes and insurance during build-out | Improvements funded by donations, grants or a loan, with up to 50 percent of rent credited back and at least 50 percent paid. The group would ask the town to keep its general liability insurance |
| Building work cited | A $41,000 estimate for exterior and other renovation work | A consultant said the town would have no financial obligation at the start |
All of these are proposal terms. The council has approved none of them.
Some details matter more to people who use the Pier every day. The cafe group said a landscaping partner had drawn up plans that keep the public restrooms open to the public. The cafe's owner said Cool Beans used to run from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. and would likely keep those hours or stay open until 7 p.m. Asked about alcohol, a presenter said the group was open to applying for a beer and wine license again but did not need one.
A Cafe That Never Left Kingstown Road for Long
The Cool Beans part of the proposal has a recent history. In August 2025, WPRI reported that the cafe had to leave its spot off Kingstown Road in Narragansett Pier, and an employee confirmed a move-out date of September 30. The cafe, known for locally roasted organic coffee, acai bowls and baked goods, thanked customers for 15 years of support. Its letter to customers, quoted by WPRI, described what the room had been:
"It's where locals gather to chat in the mornings, where students study between classes, where regulars catch up over coffee, and where summer tourists become lifelong customers."
The same letter said the cafe was "actively exploring our next location." By October 2025, the Providence Journal reported that the cafe had closed after losing its lease, and added that it was "not the end of their story." A year on, the proposed next location is the former library on the same road.
What the Council Asked the Two Groups to Do
Council Member Jason Colonies said a coffee shop, a theater and the studio could all work together in the building. He also said 1,500 square feet was not big enough for a theater and asked the two groups to talk. Council Member Donna Vignali called both proposals wonderful and said a joint arrangement "would make our lives a lot easier," as Uprise RI reported.
Council President Pro Tem James Durkin also suggested the groups meet soon. His questions were about the building's surroundings rather than its rooms, and they show what the council wants to protect:
- Keeping the two maple trees on the site
- Keeping four firefighter parking spaces on a parcel the building shares with the town's public safety complex
- Leaving room for a possible gathering spot at Caswell Street if a bike path reaches that corner
The cafe and studio group agreed to all three.
The council member who led the session said the council was not forcing a partnership. If the two groups cannot reach a deal, the council will consider each proposal on its own. No vote was taken and no date was set for a lease decision.
Whichever way it goes, the parcel carries the same fixed pieces: a 9,139-square-foot building from 1976, a 17-space lot, the Comfort Station's public restrooms and two maple trees the council has asked to keep.
ONE Residential keeps track of how the Pier's public buildings and storefronts change, because they shape the streets around them. If you own near Kingstown Road or Caswell Street and want to talk through what a new use at the old library could mean for your corner of the Pier, ONE Residential would be glad to arrange a Private Consultation.